When Technology ChangesWho Gets to Make the Music?
A Different Look at the Human and AI Music Conversation
This month's Music Topic is a spin-off from our earlier discussion, “The Controversial Subject: Who's Making the Music?”
That conversation opened the door to different opinions about AI, musicianship, and how technology is changing the way music can be created.
Because of the reaction to that subject, I thought it was worth going a little deeper.
Music has always changed whenever new technology enters the picture.
Sometimes the change is welcomed.
Sometimes it creates an argument.
And sometimes people immediately start asking:
“Is that still real music?”
We've heard versions of that question before.
Sampling changed how music could be produced. Drum machines changed how rhythms could be created. Digital recording changed the studio. Software made it possible to build entire productions without a room full of musicians.
Now AI has stepped into the conversation.
And this time, the debate feels especially personal.
For some musicians, after years of practicing and developing a craft over time, they're not really fond of this new technology.
So when technology allows someone to create music without following that same path, it can raise some understandable questions.
But there is another side to the conversation.
What about someone who has always loved music, but never had the ability to sing or play an instrument?
And who decides?
If technology finally gives that person a way to express an idea, should that automatically be dismissed?
That is where this subject starts getting complicated.
Because the discussion isn't only about AI.
It's also about creativity, access, musicianship, technology, and who gets to participate in making music.
And there may not be one perspective that fits everybody.
So where does that leave the future of music?
And what happens when someone who has spent years performing and recording music begins looking at AI from a different perspective than many of their fellow musicians?
That's where this month's full discussion begins.
Continue on MusikTopics
Human Music vs. AI Music?
The full October article goes deeper into the different perspectives surrounding traditional musicians, AI users, creativity, technology, and the people beginning to work somewhere between both worlds.
Read the Full Article on MusikTopics →
Revisit a Previous Music Topic
From the Archive
Keep Moving Forward
Revisit September's Music Topics preview about continuing forward even when support, opportunities, or results don't arrive the way you expected.
Read September Article →